Value Averaging vs Dollar-Cost Averaging: Which Works Better?
Compare value averaging with dollar-cost averaging on the same prices: how each decides what to buy, the average cost, the cash each needs and the trade-offs.
Published
Free tool: Dollar-Cost Averaging CalculatorDollar-cost averaging invests the same amount every month. Value averaging, proposed by Michael Edleson in 1988, instead adjusts each month's amount so your account grows along a target path, buying more after falls and less, or even selling, after rises. This guide compares the two on the same prices, using the free Dollar-Cost Averaging Calculator. For investing a lump sum instead, see Dollar-Cost Averaging vs Lump Sum.
How each works
- Dollar-cost averaging (DCA): invest a fixed amount, such as $1,000, every month whatever the price.
- Value averaging (VA): set a target value that rises by a fixed amount, such as $1,000 a month. Each month, invest whatever brings the account up to the target, or sell the excess if it's above.
Example: a fall and a recovery
A fund's price over six months: $10, $8, $5, $8, $10, $12.
Dollar-cost averaging, $1,000 a month:
| Month | Price | Invested | Shares bought | Total shares |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $10 | $1,000 | 100.00 | 100.00 |
| 2 | $8 | $1,000 | 125.00 | 225.00 |
| 3 | $5 | $1,000 | 200.00 | 425.00 |
| 4 | $8 | $1,000 | 125.00 | 550.00 |
| 5 | $10 | $1,000 | 100.00 | 650.00 |
| 6 | $12 | $1,000 | 83.33 | 733.33 |
Result: $6,000 invested, 733.33 shares worth $8,800 at $12, an average cost of $8.18 a share.
Value averaging, target +$1,000 a month:
| Month | Price | Value before | Target | Buy or sell | Total shares |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $10 | $0 | $1,000 | Buy $1,000 | 100 |
| 2 | $8 | $800 | $2,000 | Buy $1,200 | 250 |
| 3 | $5 | $1,250 | $3,000 | Buy $1,750 | 600 |
| 4 | $8 | $4,800 | $4,000 | Sell $800 | 500 |
| 5 | $10 | $5,000 | $5,000 | — | 500 |
| 6 | $12 | $6,000 | $6,000 | — | 500 |
Result: $3,950 invested and $800 taken out, a net $3,150, for 500 shares worth $6,000. The shares bought cost an average of $6.58.
Comparing fairly
Value averaging used less money, so the fair comparison counts the cash it didn't invest. Someone saving $1,000 a month would have $6,000 + $0 under DCA and $6,000 of shares plus $2,850 of uninvested cash under VA:
| Dollar-cost averaging | Value averaging | |
|---|---|---|
| Money saved | $6,000 | $6,000 |
| Ending value of the shares | $8,800 | $6,000 |
| Cash not invested | $0 | $2,850 |
| Total | $8,800 | $8,850 |
| Biggest single contribution | $1,000 | $1,750 |
On this path VA came out slightly ahead, because it bought heavily at the $5 low and sold a little near the top. But it needed $1,750 in month 3, more than the $1,000 saved that month, so it only works with a cash reserve.
In a steadily rising market
Now suppose the price simply climbs: $10, $11, $12, $13, $14, $15.
| Dollar-cost averaging | Value averaging | |
|---|---|---|
| Invested | $6,000 | $4,803 |
| Shares at the end | 489.26 | 400 |
| Value of the shares at $15 | $7,339 | $6,000 |
| Cash not invested | $0 | $1,197 |
| Total | $7,339 | $7,197 |
As the price rises, each month's gain counts toward the target, so value averaging invests less and less, from $1,000 in the first month to $643 in the last. It ends with uninvested cash and trails DCA by $142. The more steadily a market rises, the more value averaging lags.
Why DCA buys cheaply, too
DCA's fixed dollar amount automatically buys more shares when prices are low. That's why its average cost, $8.18, is below the average price over the six months, $8.83. Value averaging pushes the same idea further by varying the amount.
The trade-offs of value averaging
- It needs flexible cash. After a crash, the required contribution can be several times the usual amount, exactly when money may be tight.
- It holds cash in rising markets. If prices climb steadily, VA invests less and less, and uninvested cash earns less than the market.
- It can mean selling, which in a taxable account creates capital gains tax and trading costs.
- It takes more work: you must calculate each month's amount.
Practical middle paths
- Invest a fixed amount, plus extra after big drops, with a cap you can afford.
- Use value averaging without selling: skip contributions when you're above target instead of taking money out.
- Keep it automatic. For most people, regular investing through payroll or an automatic transfer is the most important habit, whichever method they use.
Try it with the Dollar-Cost Averaging Calculator
- Open the Dollar-Cost Averaging Calculator and choose a price path, or enter your own, such as 10, 8, 5, 8, 10, 12.
- Enter the amount and the number of months.
- Compare the average cost, the shares bought and the final value with investing it all at once.
Frequently asked questions
Does value averaging beat dollar-cost averaging?
Sometimes, especially when prices fall and recover. But comparisons that ignore its uninvested cash, and the larger contributions it demands, overstate the advantage.
Is value averaging good for retirement accounts?
It avoids taxes on selling inside an IRA or 401(k), but contribution limits can stop you from making the large contributions it calls for after a fall.
What target growth should I use?
Pick a monthly increase you can sustain, and allow for the extra after market drops. Some versions also raise the target for expected returns.