Dollar-Cost Averaging vs Lump Sum: Which Is Better?
Learn how dollar-cost averaging works, why a lump sum usually wins when markets rise, when spreading out your investment pays off and what research says.
Published
Free tool: Dollar-Cost Averaging CalculatorIf you have a lump sum to invest, such as a bonus, an inheritance or the proceeds of a sale, you can put it all in at once or spread it out over several months. Spreading it out is called dollar-cost averaging. This guide compares the two with worked examples, using the free Dollar-Cost Averaging Calculator.
How dollar-cost averaging works
You invest the same amount at regular intervals, such as $1,000 a month for 12 months instead of $12,000 today. A fixed amount buys more shares when the price is low and fewer when it's high, so your average cost per share ends up below the average price over the same months.
On a price that swings between about $90 and $110 with no trend, monthly purchases average $99.28 a share against an average price of $100.00.
Five price paths
Investing $12,000 at once against $1,000 a month for 12 months, with waiting cash earning 4%, valued after two years:
| Price path | Lump sum | Dollar-cost averaging | Better |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steady rise, 8% a year | $13,996.80 | $13,745.62 | Lump sum |
| Early rally, then flat | $15,000.00 | $13,051.28 | Lump sum |
| Choppy, no trend | $12,000.00 | $12,317.72 | Averaging |
| Slow decline | $9,600.00 | $10,300.72 | Averaging |
| Early 25% drop, then recovery | $13,200.00 | $15,923.65 | Averaging |
The pattern is simple. When prices rise, money invested sooner earns more, so a lump sum wins. When prices fall early, averaging buys cheaper shares and wins.
What the research says
Markets rise more often than they fall, so a lump sum usually comes out ahead. Vanguard's 2023 study, "Cost averaging: Invest now or temporarily hold your cash?", looked at several markets from 1976 to 2022 and found that a lump sum beat cost averaging between 61.6% and 73.7% of the time. Cost averaging did better in the worst downturns.
When dollar-cost averaging makes sense
- Regret: if a big drop right after you invest would make you sell, spreading it out can keep you invested.
- Nervous markets: averaging limits the damage of investing everything at a peak, at the cost of a lower expected return.
- Regular saving: investing part of each paycheck, as in a 401(k), is dollar-cost averaging by default; you're simply investing money as you earn it.
If you average in, keep the waiting cash in a high-yield savings account or a money market fund, and set the schedule in advance so you don't try to time the market. In the example, 4% interest on the waiting cash adds $230.42.
How to use the Dollar-Cost Averaging Calculator
- Open the Dollar-Cost Averaging Calculator.
- Enter the amount to invest and the number of months to spread it over.
- Enter the interest rate on cash waiting to be invested.
- Choose a price path, or choose "My own prices" and enter monthly prices, such as an index fund's month-end prices.
- Read the results: which approach ends ahead and by how much, each final value, your average cost per share against the average price, charts of the price path and both portfolios, and a month-by-month table.
For your average cost across several purchases, see How to Calculate Your Average Cost per Share.
Frequently asked questions
Is dollar-cost averaging a good strategy?
It lowers the risk of investing everything just before a fall, but in rising markets it usually earns less than investing a lump sum right away.
How long should I spread a lump sum over?
Periods of 3 to 12 months are common. The longer you wait, the more you're likely to miss in a rising market.
Does dollar-cost averaging lower my average cost?
Yes. A fixed amount buys more shares when prices are low, so your average cost per share is below the average price on the same dates.