Stock Dividends vs Stock Splits vs Cash Dividends
Compare stock splits, stock dividends and cash dividends: what each does to your shares, the price and your cost basis, and which ones are taxed.
Published
Free tool: Stock Split CalculatorCompanies can hand shareholders more shares or more cash. A stock split, a stock dividend and a cash dividend can sound similar, but they do different things to your share count, your cost basis and your tax bill. This guide compares them side by side, with the free Stock Split Calculator. For splits on their own, see How Stock Splits Work.
What each one is
- Stock split: every share becomes several, such as 2 for 1. The share price falls by the same ratio.
- Stock dividend: the company issues new shares in proportion to what you own, such as 5% more. It works like a small split.
- Cash dividend: the company pays out cash per share. The money leaves the company, so the share price drops by about the dividend.
A side-by-side example
You own 200 shares at $50, worth $10,000, that you bought for $8,000 ($40 a share).
| Shares | Price after | Value | Cost basis per share | Taxed now? | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before | 200 | $50.00 | $10,000 | $40.00 | — |
| 2-for-1 split | 400 | about $25.00 | $10,000 | $20.00 | No |
| 5% stock dividend | 210 | about $47.62 | $10,000 | $38.10 | No |
| $1.00 cash dividend | 200 | about $49.00 | $9,800 shares + $200 cash | $40.00 | Yes |
Splits and stock dividends just cut the same company into more pieces: your share of it and your total value don't change. Only the cash dividend moves money from the company to you.
Cost basis
For splits and stock dividends, your original cost spreads across all the shares you now hold:
- 2-for-1 split: $8,000 ÷ 400 = $20.00 a share.
- 5% stock dividend: $8,000 ÷ 210 = $38.10 a share.
The new shares count as held for as long as the old ones, so a later sale can still be a long-term gain. Brokers usually adjust this for you, but it's worth checking, especially for shares moved between brokers.
Taxes
- Splits and most stock dividends aren't taxed when you receive them, under IRS rules. You pay tax only when you sell.
- A stock dividend is taxable if you could have chosen cash instead, or in a few other cases, such as when some shareholders get cash and others get shares.
- Cash dividends are taxed in the year you receive them, whether or not you reinvest. As qualified dividends taxed at 15%, the $200 above would cost $30.
Fractional shares
Splits and stock dividends often produce fractions: a 5% dividend on 210 shares would give 10.5 new shares. Most companies pay cash in lieu of the half share, and that cash is taxed as if you'd sold the fraction.
Why companies choose each
- Splits bring a high share price down, which makes it easier to buy whole shares and to trade options. They usually follow a strong run in the stock.
- Stock dividends reward shareholders while keeping cash in the business, and are more common outside the US.
- Cash dividends return profits the company doesn't need for growth, and signal confidence in its earnings.
- Reverse splits combine shares to lift a low price, often to stay above an exchange's minimum. They're sometimes a warning sign.
In the company's accounts
None of these changes the value of the business, but the books record them differently. A cash dividend reduces cash and retained earnings. A stock dividend moves an amount from retained earnings into share capital, at market value for small dividends and at par value for large ones, usually above 20% to 25%. A split changes only the share count and the par value per share.
Try it with the Stock Split Calculator
- Open the Stock Split Calculator and enter your shares, the price and your total cost basis.
- Enter the ratio: 2 for 1 for a split, or 21 for 20 for a 5% stock dividend.
- Read your new share count, price and cost basis per share, and any cash for a fractional share.
Frequently asked questions
Is a stock dividend better than a cash dividend?
Not in value: both leave you with the same total. A cash dividend gives you money to spend but is taxed now; a stock dividend usually isn't taxed until you sell.
Do splits make a stock go up?
The split itself doesn't change the company's value. Any price rise after a split reflects the business and investor sentiment, not the split.
How do I enter a stock dividend in the Stock Split Calculator?
As a ratio of new to old shares: a 10% stock dividend is 11 for 10, and a 5% one is 21 for 20.