Sharpe Ratio vs Sortino Ratio: Measuring Risk-Adjusted Return

Learn how to calculate the Sharpe and Sortino ratios, what they say about a fund's return for its risk, how to annualize them and where they mislead.

Published

Free tool: Sharpe Ratio Calculator

Two funds returned 7% a year on average. One got there smoothly, the other with stomach-churning swings. Which was better? Risk-adjusted return measures like the Sharpe and Sortino ratios answer that. This guide shows how to calculate them, using the free Sharpe Ratio Calculator.

The Sharpe ratio

Sharpe ratio = (average return − risk-free rate) ÷ standard deviation of returns

It's the extra return earned above a risk-free investment for each unit of volatility. Higher is better.

Example: two funds over 10 years

YearStock fundBalanced fund
112%8%
2−4%1%
318%11%
47%6%
5−15%−6%
622%13%
79%7%
814%9%
9−6%−1%
1011%7%

With a 4% risk-free rate:

MeasureStock fundBalanced fund
Average return6.8%5.5%
Volatility (standard deviation)11.6%5.8%
Sharpe ratio0.240.26
Downside deviation7.2%3.7%
Sortino ratio0.390.41

The stock fund returned more, but the balanced fund earned slightly more per unit of risk. For the stock fund: (6.8% − 4%) ÷ 11.6% = 0.24.

The Sortino ratio

The Sharpe ratio counts all volatility as risk, including big gains. The Sortino ratio counts only the downside:

Sortino ratio = (average return − target) ÷ downside deviation

Downside deviation looks only at returns below the target, here the risk-free rate. Because much of the stock fund's volatility was on the upside, its Sortino ratio, 0.39, is well above its Sharpe ratio.

Annualizing

With monthly returns, work out the ratio per month and multiply by √12, about 3.46. Average returns are multiplied by 12 and volatility by √12. Use √52 for weekly and √4 for quarterly returns. Always compare ratios calculated the same way.

What's a good ratio?

Above 1 is often called good and above 2 very good, but it depends on the period: in a calm bull market most funds look great. The ratios are most useful for comparing similar funds over the same years.

Where the ratios mislead

  • Short histories: a few years of data can give very different results from the long run.
  • Rare crashes: a strategy that earns steady returns until it suffers a big loss can show a high ratio until the loss happens.
  • Smoothed returns: assets that are rarely priced, such as private funds, look less volatile than they are.

Look at the worst year, the total return and the strategy itself as well.

For more on average returns, see Average Return: Arithmetic vs Geometric.

How to use the Sharpe Ratio Calculator

  1. Open the Sharpe Ratio Calculator.
  2. Choose how often the returns are measured and enter the risk-free rate.
  3. Paste your returns, one per period, and optionally a second set to compare, such as an index.
  4. Read the results: the Sharpe and Sortino ratios, the average and compound returns, volatility and downside deviation for both, with a chart of the returns and a comparison table.

Frequently asked questions

What does a negative Sharpe ratio mean?

That the investment returned less than the risk-free rate, so you'd have done better in Treasury bills without the risk.

Which risk-free rate should I use?

A Treasury bill yield for the same period as the returns. Use the average over the period if rates changed a lot.

Is a higher Sortino ratio better than a higher Sharpe ratio?

They answer slightly different questions. The Sortino ratio is more useful when returns are lopsided, with bigger gains than losses or the reverse.

Share this post :