Sequence of Returns Risk: Why Early Losses Hurt Retirees Most
See why the order of returns matters once you start withdrawing, with side-by-side examples and real retirements since 1929, and how to protect your plan.
Published
Free tool: Drawdown & Recovery CalculatorTwo retirees can earn exactly the same returns over 10 years and end up with very different amounts, just because the good and bad years came in a different order. That's sequence of returns risk, and it's one of the biggest dangers in the first years of retirement. This guide shows why, using the free Drawdown & Recovery Calculator. For the math of losses, see Drawdowns Explained.
Without withdrawals, order doesn't matter
Take ten yearly returns: −20%, −10%, 5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, 15%, 10%, 5% and 12%. They average 6.20% and compound at 5.49% a year. With nothing taken out, $1,000,000 grows to $1,707,228 whether the losses come first or last, because multiplying the same numbers in any order gives the same answer.
With withdrawals, it matters a lot
Now take out $60,000 at the start of each year:
| Year | Losses first | Losses last |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | $752,000 | $1,052,800 |
| 2 | $622,800 | $1,042,440 |
| 3 | $590,940 | $1,080,684 |
| 4 | $584,034 | $1,173,787 |
| 5 | $602,639 | $1,336,544 |
| 6 | $651,167 | $1,468,026 |
| 7 | $679,842 | $1,548,828 |
| 8 | $681,826 | $1,563,269 |
| 9 | $652,917 | $1,352,943 |
| 10 | $664,068 | $1,034,354 |
Same returns, same withdrawals, but a $370,286 difference after 10 years. When the losses come first, withdrawals are taken from a shrunken portfolio, and that money is gone before the recovery arrives.
Real retirements since 1929
What happened to $1,000,000 in 60% stocks and 40% 10-year Treasuries, rebalanced yearly, withdrawing $40,000 in the first year and raising it with inflation. Values are in the retirement year's dollars:
| Retired at the start of | After 10 years | After 20 years | After 30 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1929 | $872,350 | $439,523 | $523,735 |
| 1937 | $525,931 | $505,316 | $325,702 |
| 1966 | $486,189 | $182,073 | Ran out in 1991 |
| 1969 | $434,553 | $231,562 | Ran out in 1996 |
| 1973 | $409,173 | $389,225 | $231,720 |
| 1982 | $2,284,044 | $4,450,831 | $5,360,383 |
| 1990 | $1,947,050 | $1,601,736 | $2,850,084 |
| 2000 | $616,059 | $713,149 | $648,343 after 26 years |
The 1966 and 1969 retirees ran out because poor stock returns and high inflation in the 1970s came early, while withdrawals kept rising with prices. The 1982 retiree, with the same plan, started into one of the best bull markets in history and ended with more than five times the starting amount in real terms.
Do buffers and spending cuts help?
Some, though they're no cure. In the losses-first example:
| Approach | After 10 years |
|---|---|
| Withdraw $60,000 a year from the portfolio | $664,068 |
| Keep two years of withdrawals, $120,000, in cash and spend it first | $689,676 |
| Cut the withdrawal 10%, to $54,000, in each year after a loss | $691,099 |
| Losses last instead of first, for comparison | $1,034,354 |
A cash buffer avoids selling stocks at the bottom, and small spending cuts after bad years leave more money to recover. Each added about $25,000 here, a fraction of the $370,286 the order of returns made. The bigger protection is a withdrawal rate the plan can survive even if the bad years come first.
The danger zone
The years just before and after retirement matter most: that's when your balance is largest and withdrawals begin. A 30% fall at 45 can be made up by years of saving; a 30% fall at 66, while withdrawing, can permanently shrink what the money can pay for.
How to reduce the risk
- Keep a cash or bond buffer of one to three years of spending, so you don't have to sell stocks after a fall.
- Be flexible with spending. Skipping inflation raises, or cutting back 10% after a bad year, sharply improves the odds.
- Start with a lower withdrawal rate. See The 4% Rule for how rates have fared.
- Hold more bonds around retirement, then let the stock share rise again as the danger zone passes, sometimes called a bond tent.
- Cover essentials with guaranteed income, such as Social Security, which grows if you delay claiming, a pension or an annuity.
- Work a little longer, or part-time, to reduce early withdrawals.
Try it with the calculators
- Open the Drawdown & Recovery Calculator and enter a loss, such as 30%, to see the gain and time needed to recover.
- Paste a price history to see how deep and long past drawdowns were.
- Test your own plan with the Monte Carlo Simulator, which runs thousands of return sequences, including bad early ones.
Frequently asked questions
Does sequence risk matter while I'm still saving?
Much less. While you're adding money, early losses even help, because your contributions buy at lower prices. The risk peaks once withdrawals begin.
Can I avoid sequence risk entirely?
Only by not depending on market returns, for example with annuities or bonds that mature when you need the money. Most retirees reduce the risk rather than remove it.
Why do the historical results differ so much?
Because the order of the decades differed: the same plan met the 1970s in one case and the 1980s and 1990s in another.