IV Crush: Why Options Lose Value After Earnings
Learn why option prices often collapse after earnings even when the stock moves, how to read the market's implied move, and strategies around IV crush.
Published
Free tool: Implied Volatility CalculatorYou buy a call before earnings, the company beats expectations, the stock rises, and your option still loses money. The culprit is often IV crush: the sudden drop in implied volatility once the news is out. This guide shows how it works with a worked example, using the free Implied Volatility Calculator. For the basics, see Implied Volatility and the Expected Move.
Why implied volatility rises before news
Before earnings, nobody knows whether the stock will jump or drop, so options that pay off on a big move are in demand. Option sellers charge more for that risk, and the extra shows up as higher implied volatility. Once the results are out, the uncertainty is gone, and implied volatility falls back, often within minutes of the open.
A worked example
A stock trades at $100 the day before earnings. A $100 straddle, a call and a put at the same strike, expires in 7 days. With implied volatility at 80%, the call costs $4.46 and the put $4.37: $8.83 for the straddle, or $883 per contract.
The next morning, earnings are out, 6 days remain and implied volatility has fallen to 35%. Here's the straddle's value and the profit or loss on one contract, depending on where the stock opens:
| Stock after earnings | Call | Put | Straddle | Profit or loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $85 | $0.00 | $14.93 | $14.93 | +$609 |
| $90 | $0.01 | $9.94 | $9.95 | +$112 |
| $95 | $0.28 | $5.21 | $5.50 | −$334 |
| $100 | $1.83 | $1.75 | $3.58 | −$525 |
| $105 | $5.39 | $0.31 | $5.70 | −$313 |
| $110 | $10.10 | $0.03 | $10.13 | +$130 |
| $115 | $15.08 | $0.00 | $15.08 | +$624 |
A 5% move either way still loses money. The straddle only profits on a move of roughly 9% or more.
Where the loss comes from
With the stock unchanged at $100:
- One day of time decay, at the old 80% volatility, would take the straddle from $8.83 to $8.18: −$0.65.
- The drop from 80% to 35% volatility takes it from $8.18 to $3.58: −$4.60.
Almost all the loss is the volatility crush, not the passage of time.
The market's implied move
A rule of thumb: the price of the at-the-money straddle just before earnings is about the move the market expects. Here it's $8.83, or about 8.8%. Buyers of options need the stock to move more than that; sellers profit if it moves less. It's a useful check on your own expectations: if you think the stock will move 5%, buying options at an 8.8% implied move is likely to lose.
Who wins from IV crush
Option sellers. Selling a straddle, a strangle or an iron condor before earnings collects the inflated premium, and the crush works in the seller's favor. The risk is a move much bigger than expected: a short straddle loses without limit, so most traders use defined-risk structures such as iron condors.
How buyers can deal with it
- Trade the stock instead, if you have a view on the direction.
- Use spreads. In a bull call spread, the option you sell loses value from the crush too, offsetting much of the loss on the one you buy.
- Buy earlier, before implied volatility climbs, and consider selling before the announcement.
- Calendar spreads sell the near-term option, which carries the inflated volatility, and buy a later one that's less affected.
- Compare the implied move with past earnings moves, to judge whether options are cheap or expensive.
Not just earnings
Implied volatility also builds before other scheduled events, such as product launches, court rulings, drug trial results and central bank announcements, and collapses after them in the same way.
Try it with the Implied Volatility Calculator
- Open the Implied Volatility Calculator and enter an option's price before an event, with the stock price, strike and days left.
- Note the implied volatility and the expected move.
- Use the Black-Scholes Calculator to price the same option at a lower volatility, as it might be after the news, and see how much value would vanish.
Frequently asked questions
How much does implied volatility usually drop after earnings?
It varies by stock. The near-term options often lose a large part of their implied volatility; options expiring months later fall much less.
Can IV crush happen if the stock moves a lot?
Yes, but a big enough move can outweigh it. In the example, the straddle was profitable when the stock moved more than about 9%.
Does IV crush affect long-term options?
Much less. An event matters less to an option with months to run, so its implied volatility barely rises before the event and barely falls after.