Is Buying on Margin Worth It? The Math of Leverage

Leverage magnifies returns in both directions. See when margin pays after interest, how volatility and margin calls work against you, and safer ways to use it.

Published

Free tool: Margin Calculator

Buying on margin means borrowing from your broker to buy more stock than your cash allows. It magnifies gains, but also losses, and the interest and margin calls stack the odds against you more than most people expect. This guide does the math, using the free Margin Calculator. For the rules and mechanics, see How Buying on Margin Works.

How leverage changes your return

With $10,000 of your own money and a $10,000 margin loan at 8% a year, you control $20,000 of stock, twice your cash. Your return on your own money is:

Return on your money = 2 × stock return − 8% interest

Stock return in a yearWithout marginWith 2× margin
−30%−30%−68%
−20%−20%−48%
−10%−10%−28%
0%0%−8%
+10%+10%+12%
+20%+20%+32%
+30%+30%+52%

Two things stand out. Losses grow twice as fast as gains, after interest. And a flat year isn't flat: it costs you 8%.

The break-even rule

Leverage only helps when the investment earns more than the interest rate. At 2× leverage, your return beats the unleveraged one only when the stock returns more than 8%: at +10% you make 12% instead of 10%, a gain of just 2 points for twice the risk.

Margin rates vary widely: brokers aimed at active traders charge a few points above short-term interest rates, while many large brokers charge 10% or more on smaller loans. Check your rate before doing the math.

Volatility hurts leveraged returns

Even when a stock ends where it started, leverage can leave you with less. Suppose it rises 25% and then falls 20%, back to where it began:

Stock onlyWith 2× margin at 8%
Start$10,000$10,000 equity ($20,000 of stock, $10,000 loan)
After +25%$12,500$14,200 ($25,000 of stock, $10,800 owed)
After −20%$10,000$8,336 ($20,000 of stock, $11,664 owed)
Change0%−16.6%

The loan grows with interest whatever the stock does, so after two years the leveraged investor has lost 16.6% on a stock that went nowhere.

Margin calls come at the worst time

Your broker requires your equity to stay above a maintenance level: at least 25% of the account's value under FINRA rules, and often 30% to 40% at brokers. Below it, you must add cash or the broker sells your shares, usually after a fall, locking in the loss.

How far the price can fall before a margin call, with 50% borrowed:

Maintenance requirementMargin call priceFall from $100
25%$66.67−33.3%
30%$71.43−28.6%
40%$83.33−16.7%

Borrowing less buys a lot of room. At a 25% requirement, a fall of 33.3% triggers a call when you borrow as much as your own money, 55.6% when you borrow half as much, and 73.3% when you borrow a quarter as much.

Falls of a third or more aren't rare: the S&P 500 fell about that much or more in 1987, 2000–2002, 2007–2009 and 2020, and individual stocks fall that far much more often.

Taxes

Margin interest on money borrowed to buy taxable investments can be deducted as investment interest expense, but only if you itemize, and only up to your net investment income for the year (IRS Form 4952). Interest on money used to buy tax-exempt municipal bonds isn't deductible.

Using margin more safely

  • Borrow far less than the maximum. A small loan gives a much bigger cushion before a margin call.
  • Keep cash ready to meet a margin call instead of being forced to sell.
  • Don't use margin for long-term holdings you can't afford to see sold at the bottom of a crash.
  • Know your rate and the house maintenance requirement, which can rise without warning for volatile stocks.
  • Consider defined-risk alternatives, such as buying a call option, where the most you can lose is the premium.

Try it with the Margin Calculator

  1. Open the Margin Calculator and enter your cash, the amount you borrow and the share price.
  2. Enter the maintenance requirement, the interest rate and how long you'll hold.
  3. Try different price changes to see your leveraged return, the interest cost and the price that would trigger a margin call.

Frequently asked questions

Is margin trading ever a good idea?

It can make sense for short periods, small amounts and investors who understand the risks, such as covering a short gap before cash arrives. For long-term investing, most people are better off without it.

Can you lose more than you invested with margin?

Yes. If prices fall fast, your account can go below zero before the broker sells, and you owe the difference.

How is margin interest charged?

Daily, on the amount borrowed, and usually added to your loan each month. Rates typically fall as the loan gets bigger.

Share this post :