Index Funds vs Actively Managed Funds: Costs and Results

Compare index and actively managed funds on fees, long-run results and taxes, and see what a 0.64% versus 0.05% expense ratio costs over 30 years.

Published

Free tool: Investment Fee Calculator

An index fund buys every stock or bond in a market index and accepts the market's return. An actively managed fund pays managers to pick investments, aiming to beat that index. The difference in cost is large, and over decades it adds up to a large difference in wealth. This guide compares them, using the free Investment Fee Calculator. For how fees compound in general, see How Investment Fees Add Up.

The cost gap

According to the Investment Company Institute, the average expense ratios in 2025, weighted by assets, were:

Fund typeAverage expense ratio
Actively managed stock mutual funds0.64%
Index stock mutual funds0.05%
Index stock ETFs0.14%
Actively managed bond mutual funds0.44%
Index bond mutual funds0.05%

The average active stock fund costs more than 12 times as much as the average index stock fund.

What the gap costs over 30 years

$100,000 invested for 30 years, earning 7% a year before fees:

Yearly costValue after 30 yearsLess than the 0.05% fund
0.05% (index fund)$750,626—
0.64% (average active fund)$635,843$114,783
1.00%$574,349$176,277
1.64% (active fund plus a 1% advisory fee)$478,931$271,695

A fee of 0.64% looks small next to a 7% return, but over 30 years it costs about 15% of the final balance, before any taxes.

Active funds have to win by their costs just to tie

Before costs, all investors together earn the market's return, because together they own the market. That means the average actively managed dollar must trail the index by roughly its extra costs, a point Nobel laureate William Sharpe made in "The Arithmetic of Active Management." In the example, an active fund must beat the index by 0.59 points a year, after its trading costs, just to match the index fund.

What the results show

S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes its SPIVA reports twice a year, comparing active funds with their benchmarks. They've consistently found that most actively managed US stock funds trail their benchmark over 10 to 15 years. Its persistence studies have also found that few top-performing funds stay at the top in the following years, so past winners are hard to pick in advance.

Taxes widen the gap

In a taxable account, active funds tend to trade more, and selling winners passes capital gains on to shareholders, taxed even if you reinvest them. Index funds trade little, and index ETFs can usually avoid distributing gains at all. In an IRA or 401(k) this doesn't matter, because gains aren't taxed until you withdraw.

When active management can make sense

  • Some investors value a specific strategy, such as a dividend focus or a particular style, that no low-cost index matches.
  • Some markets are less efficient, such as small companies or certain bond markets, where skilled managers may have more room to add value.
  • Behavior matters. A fund or adviser that keeps you invested through a crash can be worth more than its fee, if you'd otherwise sell at the bottom.

If you choose active funds, favor low-cost ones: low fees are among the best predictors of a fund's future relative results.

Comparing funds

  • Expense ratio: the ongoing yearly cost, listed in the prospectus.
  • Turnover: how much of the portfolio is traded each year; high turnover means hidden trading costs and, in taxable accounts, taxes.
  • After-tax returns, listed in the prospectus, for taxable accounts.
  • What the fund actually holds, compared with an index fund: some "active" funds stay so close to the index that you pay active fees for an index return.

Try it with the Investment Fee Calculator

  1. Open the Investment Fee Calculator and enter your starting amount, monthly contributions, years and expected return.
  2. Enter two fees to compare, such as 0.05% for an index fund and 0.64% for an active one, or add an advisory fee.
  3. Read the difference in your final balance, the fees paid and the growth lost.

Frequently asked questions

Are index funds risk-free?

No. An index fund carries the full risk of its market: a stock index fund falls as much as the stock market does. It removes the risk of a manager doing worse than the market.

Are ETFs better than index mutual funds?

They're similar for long-term investors. ETFs trade throughout the day and are often more tax-efficient; index mutual funds can be easier for automatic investing.

What expense ratio is reasonable?

For broad stock and bond index funds, many cost 0.10% or less. For active funds, the lower the better.

Share this post :