How to Judge a Dividend Stock: Yield, Payout Ratio and Growth
Learn how to evaluate a dividend stock using its yield, payout ratio and dividend growth, how to spot a yield trap, and how dividends are taxed.
Published
Free tool: Dividend Discount Model CalculatorA high dividend yield catches the eye, but it's only one of the numbers that tell you whether a dividend is attractive and safe. This guide shows how to read a dividend stock's yield, payout ratio and growth, and how they fit together, using the free Dividend Discount Model Calculator. To value a stock from its dividends, see Dividend Discount Model Explained.
The key numbers
- Dividend yield = yearly dividend ÷ share price. What the dividend pays on today's price.
- Payout ratio = dividends ÷ earnings. The share of profit paid out. Lower leaves room to keep paying, and raising, the dividend.
- Free cash flow payout = dividends ÷ free cash flow. Dividends are paid in cash, so this is often a better test than earnings.
- Dividend growth rate: how fast the dividend has grown each year, usually over five or ten years.
Two very different dividend stocks
| Company A | Company B | |
|---|---|---|
| Share price | $50 | $80 |
| Yearly dividend | $2.00 | $1.20 |
| Dividend yield | 4.0% | 1.5% |
| Earnings per share | $2.50 | $4.00 |
| Payout ratio | 80% | 30% |
| Free cash flow per share | $2.20 | — |
| Dividend 5 years ago | $1.60 | — |
| Dividend growth a year | 4.56% | 12% |
Company A pays more now, but uses 80% of its earnings and 91% of its free cash flow to do it, leaving little room for raises. Company B pays less but keeps 70% of its earnings to reinvest, and has been raising its dividend 12% a year.
Yield on cost
If the dividends keep growing at those rates, the yield on what you paid, your yield on cost, changes over time:
| Company A | Company B | |
|---|---|---|
| Yield on cost after 10 years | 6.25% | 4.66% |
| Dividends from $10,000 in year 10 | $625 | $466 |
| Total dividends over 10 years | $5,155 | $2,948 |
| Years until B's yield on cost passes A's | — | about 14 |
Company A pays more for the first 14 years. After that, B's faster growth wins, and it also had more money left to grow the business.
Yield plus growth
The Gordon growth model gives a rough expected return:
Expected return ≈ dividend yield + dividend growth rate
That's 4.0% + 4.56% = 8.56% for Company A and 1.5% + 12% = 13.5% for Company B, if growth can last. In practice, 12% a year rarely lasts forever, so treat high growth rates with caution.
Spotting a yield trap
A very high yield often means the market expects a cut. Warning signs:
- The yield is far above similar companies, because the share price has fallen.
- The payout ratio is above 100%, so the company pays more than it earns.
- Debt is rising to fund the dividend.
- Earnings or cash flow are falling.
- The dividend hasn't grown in years.
When a company cuts its dividend, the share price usually falls too, so investors lose income and value at once.
Different rules for different businesses
Payout ratios depend on the business. Utilities often pay out most of their earnings because their profits are steady. Real estate investment trusts (REITs) must distribute at least 90% of their taxable income to keep their tax status, so judge them on funds from operations rather than earnings. Fast-growing companies often pay little or nothing and reinvest instead.
Dividend dates
- Declaration date: the company announces the dividend.
- Ex-dividend date: buy before this date to receive the dividend. With US trades settling in one day, it's usually the same as the record date.
- Payment date: the cash arrives.
On the ex-dividend date, the share price typically drops by about the dividend, so buying just before it doesn't create free money.
How dividends are taxed
Qualified dividends are taxed at the long-term capital gains rates of 0%, 15% or 20%, plus the 3.8% NIIT at higher incomes. To qualify, you must hold the shares for more than 60 days in the 121-day period that starts 60 days before the ex-dividend date. Other dividends, including most from REITs, are taxed as ordinary income.
Try it with the calculators
- Open the Dividend Discount Model Calculator and enter the dividend, its expected growth, your required return and the price, to see what the dividend stream is worth and the growth the price implies.
- Project your income with the Dividend Calculator, including reinvestment and dividend raises.
- Compare stocks on yield, payout ratio and growth together, not yield alone.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good dividend yield?
It depends on the market and the company. Compare a stock's yield with similar companies and with its own history; an unusually high yield needs a closer look.
What payout ratio is safe?
For most companies, below about 60% of earnings leaves a margin for bad years. Utilities and REITs are judged differently.
Should I reinvest dividends?
If you don't need the income, reinvesting buys more shares and compounds your return over time. See How Much Dividend Income Will I Get?.