How Short Selling Works: Costs, Margin and Risks

Learn how short selling works step by step, what it costs in borrow fees and dividends, how margin calls are triggered and why losses have no limit.

Published

Free tool: Short Selling Calculator

Short selling lets you profit when a stock falls: you sell shares you've borrowed and buy them back later, hopefully for less. It's simple in principle, but the costs and risks are different from buying a stock. This guide walks through them with the free Short Selling Calculator.

How short selling works

  1. Borrow the shares through your broker, in a margin account.
  2. Sell them at today's price. The proceeds stay in your account.
  3. Pay the costs while you're short: a borrow fee, and any dividends the stock pays, which you owe the lender.
  4. Buy the shares back, called covering, and return them. If you buy back for less than you sold, you profit.

Example

You short 100 shares at $50 and buy them back at $40 after 60 days. The borrow fee is 3% a year and the stock pays a $0.50 dividend.

  • Gain on the shares: ($50 − $40) × 100 = $1,000
  • Borrow fee: about $22.50, charged daily on the shares' value over a 360-day year
  • Dividend owed: $50
  • Profit: $927.50, a 37.1% return on your $2,500 deposit
  • Break-even: about $49.25, the price you must buy back below to make money

Profit or loss as the price moves

Price changeBuy-back priceProfit or lossReturn on deposit
−50%$25.00$2,431.2597.3%
−25%$37.50$1,178.1347.1%
−10%$45.00$426.2517.1%
0%$50.00−$75.00−3.0%
+10%$55.00−$576.25−23.1%
+25%$62.50−$1,328.13−53.1%
+50%$75.00−$2,581.25−103.3%
+100%$100.00−$5,087.50−203.5%

The most you can make is the sale price, if the stock goes to zero. The loss has no limit: if the stock doubles, you lose more than twice your deposit.

Margin rules

  • Initial margin: under the Federal Reserve's Regulation T, you deposit 50% of the short sale's value on top of the proceeds, so the account holds 150%. The $5,000 short needs a $2,500 deposit.
  • Maintenance margin: FINRA Rule 4210 requires equity of at least 30% of the shares' current value, or $5 a share if greater, for stocks at $5 or more; below $5 it's $2.50 a share or 100% of the value, whichever is greater. Many brokers require more.
  • Margin call: with $7,500 in the account, equity falls below 30% when the price passes $7,500 ÷ (100 × 1.3) = $57.69, a 15.4% rise. You'd have to add money, or the broker can buy back the shares for you.

To see how margin works when buying, see How Buying on Margin Works.

Costs and risks

  • Borrow fees: most large stocks cost well under 1% a year to borrow, but hard-to-borrow stocks can cost 20%, 50% or more.
  • Short squeezes: when a heavily shorted stock jumps, short sellers rushing to buy back can push it even higher, as with GameStop in January 2021.
  • Recalls: the lender can ask for the shares back, forcing you to cover at a bad time.
  • Taxes: gains on short sales are generally short-term capital gains, taxed as ordinary income.

Buying a put option is another way to bet on a fall, with a loss limited to the price you pay; see How to Calculate Options Profit.

How to use the Short Selling Calculator

  1. Open the Short Selling Calculator.
  2. Enter the shares, the short sale price and the buy-back price, or today's price to see where you stand.
  3. Enter the days held, the borrow fee, dividends and trading costs.
  4. Set the initial and maintenance margin, 50% and 30% by default.
  5. Read the results: the profit or loss, the return on your deposit, the break-even price, the margin call price, a profit chart across prices, where the proceeds go and a table of price moves.

Frequently asked questions

Can you short any stock?

Only if your broker can borrow the shares. Some stocks are hard or impossible to borrow, and brokers can restrict shorting in volatile names.

How long can you keep a short open?

As long as you keep paying the borrow fee and meet margin requirements, unless the lender recalls the shares.

Do you earn interest on short sale proceeds?

Most retail brokers keep the interest. Some pay a rebate on large accounts.

Share this post :