ESPP vs RSUs vs Stock Options: Equity Compensation Compared
Compare ESPPs, RSUs, NSOs and ISOs: what each costs you, when and how it's taxed, the risks, and how to decide when to sell your company stock.
Published
Free tool: ESPP CalculatorMany employers pay part of their compensation in company stock. The four common forms, an employee stock purchase plan (ESPP), restricted stock units (RSUs), nonqualified stock options (NSOs) and incentive stock options (ISOs), work and are taxed very differently. This guide compares them, using the free ESPP Calculator. For ESPPs in depth, see How an ESPP Works.
At a glance
| ESPP | RSUs | NSOs | ISOs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What you get | The right to buy shares at a discount | Shares, once they vest | The right to buy shares at a set price | The right to buy shares at a set price |
| Do you pay? | Yes, from your paycheck | No | Yes, the strike price | Yes, the strike price |
| Taxed when | You sell | They vest | You exercise | You sell (AMT may apply at exercise) |
| Taxed as | Wages and capital gains | Wages | Wages, then capital gains | Capital gains if the holding rules are met |
| Worthless if the stock falls? | Rarely: you buy at a discount | No, unless the stock goes to zero | Yes, below the strike | Yes, below the strike |
RSUs
When RSUs vest, the shares' value counts as wages, taxed like salary.
- Example: 100 RSUs vest at $50, so $5,000 is added to your wages.
- Withholding: employers usually withhold federal tax at the flat 22% supplemental rate (37% above $1 million a year), here $1,100, often by selling about 22 shares.
- The gap: if your top bracket is 32%, you'll owe about $500 more when you file.
- After vesting: your cost basis is $50 a share. Selling later at $60, after more than a year, gives a $1,000 long-term capital gain.
Nonqualified stock options (NSOs)
NSOs let you buy shares at a fixed strike price. When you exercise, the gap between the market price and the strike is taxed as wages.
- Example: 100 options with a $40 strike, exercised when the stock is $50: you pay $4,000 and have $1,000 of wages.
- After exercise: your basis is $50. Selling at $60 more than a year later is a $1,000 long-term gain.
- If the stock stays below $40, the options are "underwater" and may expire worthless.
Incentive stock options (ISOs)
ISOs get special tax treatment if you hold the shares long enough.
- At exercise: no regular income tax, but the $1,000 spread counts toward the alternative minimum tax (AMT), which can trigger a tax bill.
- Qualifying sale: sell at least 2 years after the grant and 1 year after exercise, and the whole $2,000 gain from $40 to $60 is a long-term capital gain.
- Disqualifying sale: sell sooner, and the spread at exercise is taxed as ordinary income instead.
- Only $100,000 of ISOs, valued at grant, can first become exercisable in any year; the rest are treated as NSOs.
ESPPs
A qualified ESPP lets you buy shares through payroll at a discount of up to 15%, often on the lower of the price at the start and the end of the offering period.
- Example from the ESPP Calculator: contributing $5,000 over six months, with the price rising from $50 to $60 and a 15% discount with a lookback, buys 117.647 shares at $42.50, worth $7,058.82: a $2,058.82 gain at once.
- Taxes: part of the gain is taxed as wages; how much depends on whether you hold for a qualifying disposition, 2 years from the offering date and 1 year from purchase.
- Limit: $25,000 of stock a year, valued at the offering-date price.
Which is worth the most?
- RSUs have value as long as the stock is worth anything, so they're the most dependable.
- ESPPs lock in a discount, often a 15% or larger gain on day one, for money you'd have earned anyway.
- Options are worth nothing below the strike, but gain more in percentage terms when the stock soars.
Don't put too much in one basket
Your job already depends on your employer. Holding a lot of its stock as well means one bad year could cost you both your income and your savings. Many planners suggest keeping any single stock, including your employer's, to around 10% of your investments or less.
A useful test for RSUs: once they vest, keeping the shares is the same as buying them with cash. If you wouldn't buy that much with cash, consider selling at vest, which usually adds little or no tax because the gain so far is small.
Practical tips
- Plan for under-withholding on RSUs and NSOs, especially in higher brackets.
- Track cost basis carefully. Broker tax forms often show the wrong basis for ESPP and option shares, which can lead to paying tax twice.
- Watch trading windows. Insiders can usually sell only at set times.
- Get advice for ISOs, where the AMT can be large and hard to predict.
Try it with the ESPP Calculator
- Open the ESPP Calculator and enter your salary, contribution and the plan's discount and lookback.
- Enter the offering and purchase prices, and the price you expect to sell at.
- Compare the after-tax result of selling right away and of holding for a qualifying disposition.
Frequently asked questions
Should I sell RSUs as soon as they vest?
Many advisers suggest it unless you'd deliberately buy the stock with cash. The tax on vesting is the same either way.
Are RSUs taxed twice?
No, but it can look that way. The value at vest is taxed as wages, and only the change after vesting is a capital gain. Make sure your cost basis includes the amount taxed as wages.
Is an ESPP worth joining?
A plan with a 15% discount and a lookback is usually worth it if you can afford the paycheck deductions, even if you sell the shares as soon as you can.