CDs vs T-Bills vs High-Yield Savings vs Money Market Funds

Compare CDs, Treasury bills, high-yield savings accounts and money market funds on safety, access, rates and taxes, with after-tax yields for each.

Published

Free tool: CD & Bond Ladder Calculator

When you want your cash safe but still earning interest, there are four main choices: a high-yield savings account, a money market fund, a certificate of deposit (CD) and a Treasury bill. They differ in safety, access, how their rates change and, often overlooked, how they're taxed. This guide compares them, with the free CD & Bond Ladder Calculator. For spreading money across maturities, see How to Build a CD Ladder.

At a glance

High-yield savingsMoney market fundCDTreasury bill
ProtectionFDIC or NCUA insured up to $250,000Not insured; holds short-term debt and aims for $1 a shareFDIC or NCUA insured up to $250,000Backed by the US government
AccessAny timeUsually the next business dayEarly withdrawal penaltySell any time at the market price, or hold to maturity
RateVariable, can change any dayVariable, follows short-term ratesFixed for the termFixed until maturity
State income taxYesYes; Treasury funds are often partly exemptYesNo
TermsNoneNoneA few months to 5 years or more4 to 52 weeks

The FDIC limit is $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category.

After-tax yields

Taxes can change the ranking. With example yields and a 24% federal bracket, here's what each keeps after tax:

Example yieldAfter tax with 5% state taxAfter tax with 9.3% state tax
High-yield savings3.80%2.70%2.53%
Money market fund3.90%2.77%2.60%
1-year CD4.10%2.91%2.73%
26-week T-bill4.00%3.04%3.04%

On $50,000 for a year with 5% state tax, that's about $1,349 from the savings account, $1,385 from the money market fund, $1,455 from the CD and $1,520 from the T-bill. Treasury interest is free of state and local income tax, so a T-bill can beat a CD that pays more before tax, especially in high-tax states. These yields are examples; check current rates.

High-yield savings accounts

Usually offered by online banks, they pay far more than a typical branch savings account, with instant access and deposit insurance. The catch: the rate can drop at any time, and introductory rates often fade. They're the natural home for an emergency fund; see How Big Should Your Emergency Fund Be?.

Money market funds

Mutual funds that hold very short-term, high-quality debt such as Treasury bills and repurchase agreements. Government money market funds aim to keep a stable $1.00 share price, and their yield, quoted as a 7-day SEC yield, follows short-term rates closely. They aren't FDIC-insured, but they've been very stable. In a brokerage account they're a convenient place to park cash between investments.

CDs

A CD locks in a rate for a set term, from a few months to five years or more. If you withdraw early, banks usually charge a penalty, often several months of interest. Brokered CDs, bought through a brokerage, can be sold before maturity instead, but their price falls if rates have risen. Some CDs are callable, meaning the bank can end them early, usually when rates fall. For the math of a single CD, see How CDs Work.

Treasury bills

Short-term US government debt, sold at a discount to face value and paying the full value at maturity, with terms from 4 to 52 weeks. You can buy them from as little as $100 at TreasuryDirect, or through a brokerage, at regular auctions or on the secondary market. Their yield is quoted in a few ways; see How Treasury Bills Work.

Which to use when

GoalGood fit
Emergency fundHigh-yield savings or a money market fund
Money needed on a known dateA CD or T-bill maturing just before then
Locking in a rate for yearsCDs or a CD ladder
Large balance in a high-tax stateT-bills or a Treasury money market fund
Cash waiting to be investedA money market fund in your brokerage account
Steady access with better ratesA ladder of CDs or T-bills

Don't forget inflation

With inflation near 3%, an after-tax yield of 2.5% to 3% barely keeps up. These accounts protect your money's dollar value, not its buying power over decades, so they suit short-term needs rather than long-term savings.

Try it with the CD & Bond Ladder Calculator

  1. Open the CD & Bond Ladder Calculator and enter the amount and number of rungs.
  2. Enter the rates for each term, from CDs or Treasury bills.
  3. See your average yield, when money becomes available, and how a ladder compares with a single CD.

Frequently asked questions

Are money market funds the same as money market accounts?

No. A money market account is a bank deposit, insured by the FDIC; a money market fund is an investment fund, which isn't.

Are T-bills safer than CDs?

Both are very safe. T-bills are backed by the US government with no limit; CDs are insured up to $250,000 per bank. Above that, T-bills avoid spreading money across banks.

Do I pay tax on CD interest before the CD matures?

Usually yes. For CDs longer than a year, interest is generally taxable each year as it's earned, even if it stays in the CD.

Share this post :