Benjamin Graham's 7 Rules for the Defensive Investor
The seven tests Benjamin Graham set for picking stocks safely, from size and debt to the P/E × P/B limit of 22.5, with a worked example and today's numbers.
Published
Free tool: Graham Number CalculatorBenjamin Graham, the father of value investing, wrote The Intelligent Investor for ordinary people who wanted safety without spending their lives on research. He called them defensive investors, and in the book's 1973 edition he gave them seven simple tests for choosing stocks. This guide explains each, works through an example and shows how they connect to the free Graham Number Calculator. For the Graham Number itself, see The Graham Number and Graham Formula Explained.
The seven rules
| Rule | Graham's test | What it guards against |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Adequate size | At least $100 million of yearly sales for an industrial company, or $50 million of assets for a utility, in early-1970s dollars | Small companies that are more fragile |
| 2. Strong financial condition | Current assets at least twice current liabilities, and long-term debt no more than working capital | Companies that could run short of cash |
| 3. Earnings stability | Positive earnings in each of the past 10 years | Erratic, unproven businesses |
| 4. Dividend record | Dividends paid without a break for at least 20 years | Companies that can't share their profits |
| 5. Earnings growth | Earnings per share up at least a third over 10 years, comparing three-year averages | Businesses that are standing still |
| 6. Moderate P/E | No more than 15 times average earnings of the past three years | Paying too much for earnings |
| 7. Moderate price-to-book | No more than 1.5 times book value, or a P/E times P/B of no more than 22.5 | Paying too much for assets |
Prices have risen almost eightfold since 1971, by the consumer price index, so Graham's size test would be about $789 million of sales or $394 million of utility assets today.
Checking a company
Take a hypothetical tool maker, Steady Tools. Its shares trade at $48.
| Test | Steady Tools | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Size | $2.4 billion of sales | Pass |
| Current ratio | $1.15 billion of current assets ÷ $0.5 billion of current liabilities = 2.3 | Pass |
| Debt | $400 million of long-term debt vs $650 million of working capital | Pass |
| Earnings stability | Profitable in each of the last 10 years | Pass |
| Dividends | Paid for 25 years | Pass |
| Earnings growth | Three-year average EPS up from $2.10 to $3.00, +42.9% | Pass |
| P/E | $48 ÷ $3.00 average EPS = 16.0 | Fail (above 15) |
| Price-to-book | $48 ÷ $22.00 book value = 2.18; × P/E = 34.9 | Fail (above 22.5) |
Steady Tools is the kind of business Graham liked, but at $48 it's too expensive for him. The Graham Number, √(22.5 × $3.00 × $22.00) = $38.54, is the most rules 6 and 7 allow, about 20% below the market price.
Why the rules use averages
Rules 5 and 6 use three-year averages of earnings rather than one year's figure. A single year can be inflated by a boom or depressed by a recession; averaging smooths the cycle, so you don't pay a high price for a peak year.
Why few stocks pass today
- Asset-light companies, such as software firms and consumer brands, have small book values, so they fail rule 7 even at reasonable prices.
- Buybacks have partly replaced dividends, so some strong companies fail rule 4.
- Valuations are higher than in Graham's day, when P/E ratios under 15 were common.
Graham himself said his tests would exclude many companies and expected investors to adapt them. The lasting idea isn't the exact numbers but the discipline: buy established, financially sound companies, and don't overpay.
Graham's other advice for defensive investors
- Diversify across at least 10 and up to about 30 stocks.
- Hold bonds as well, never less than 25% or more than 75% in stocks, with an even split as a reasonable default. See Asset Allocation by Age for how different mixes have fared.
- Insist on a margin of safety: pay well below your estimate of value, so mistakes and bad luck don't ruin the investment.
Try it with the Graham Number Calculator
- Open the Graham Number Calculator and enter the price, earnings per share and book value per share. Use three-year average earnings to follow Graham's rules.
- Read the Graham Number and the P/E × P/B test against 22.5.
- Add expected growth and the AAA bond yield to see Graham's formula value, and a margin of safety for a buy-below price.
Frequently asked questions
Do Graham's rules still work?
They still screen out fragile and overpriced companies, but they also exclude many great businesses. Value stocks lagged growth stocks for much of the 2010s, so the rules suit patient investors.
What is Graham's enterprising investor?
Graham's second type of investor, willing to do more research. He gave them looser tests, aimed at bargains among smaller or out-of-favor companies.
What is net current asset value?
Current assets minus all liabilities. Graham's deepest bargains traded below it, though such stocks are rare today.