Asset Location: Which Investments Belong in Which Account
Learn how placing bonds, stocks and munis in the right taxable, IRA and Roth accounts can add thousands after tax, with a 20-year worked example.
Published
Free tool: Tax-Equivalent Yield CalculatorAsset allocation decides what you own. Asset location decides where you hold it: in a taxable brokerage account, a tax-deferred account such as a traditional IRA or 401(k), or a tax-free Roth. Putting each investment in the right account can add thousands of dollars after tax without changing your risk. This guide shows how, using the free Tax-Equivalent Yield Calculator. For comparing tax-free and taxable bonds, see Tax-Equivalent Yield: When Municipal Bonds Pay Off.
The three kinds of accounts
| Account | Taxed each year? | Taxed when you withdraw? | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taxable brokerage | Yes: interest, dividends and realized gains | Only on gains you haven't yet paid tax on | Tax-efficient investments |
| Traditional IRA or 401(k) | No | Yes, as ordinary income | Investments that would be taxed heavily every year |
| Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) | No | No, for qualified withdrawals | Investments with the highest expected growth |
Where each investment belongs
| Investment | Usually best in | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable bonds, CDs, bond funds | Tax-deferred | Their interest is taxed at full income rates every year |
| REITs | Tax-deferred | Most of their dividends are taxed as ordinary income |
| Actively traded or high-turnover funds | Tax-deferred | Frequent gains would be taxed each year |
| Broad stock index funds and ETFs | Taxable | Low turnover, qualified dividends and long-term gains taxed at lower rates |
| International stock funds | Taxable | The foreign tax credit can only be claimed in a taxable account |
| Municipal bonds | Taxable only | Already tax-free; wasted in an IRA |
| Highest-growth investments | Roth | All the growth is tax-free |
A 20-year example
You have $100,000 in a taxable account and $100,000 in a traditional IRA, and want half in stocks and half in bonds. Stocks return 7% a year, including a 1.5% qualified dividend; bonds yield 4.5%. You pay 24% federal and 5% state income tax, and 15% plus 5% state on qualified dividends and long-term gains. After 20 years, everything is withdrawn or sold:
| Bonds in taxable, stocks in IRA | Stocks in taxable, bonds in IRA | |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable account | $187,574 | $365,838 before tax on the gain |
| Taxable account after selling | $187,574 | $322,193 |
| IRA after 29% tax on withdrawal | $274,748 | $171,232 |
| Total after tax | $462,322 | $493,424 |
Same investments, same returns, but putting the bonds in the IRA leaves $31,102 more, about 6.7%. If the stocks are never sold and pass to heirs, who generally get a stepped-up cost basis, the second approach is worth $537,069, about $75,000 more.
Where municipal bonds fit
If you need bonds in a taxable account, compare taxable bonds with munis. In the example, a 4.5% taxable bond keeps 3.195% after 29% tax. A 3.5% municipal bond, free of federal and in-state tax, grows $100,000 to $198,979 in 20 years, against $187,574 for the taxable bond. At this tax rate the muni's tax-equivalent yield is 4.93%, more than the 4.5% taxable bond.
The Roth: save it for growth
Everything in a Roth grows tax-free, so it's the best home for the investments you expect to grow most, such as stocks. Putting bonds there "wastes" tax-free space on low returns, though that's a smaller cost than putting high-yield bonds in a taxable account.
Things to watch
- Allocation comes first. Decide your overall mix, then place it; don't let tax savings push you into more risk than you want.
- Rebalancing gets harder when stocks and bonds are in different accounts, since moving money between accounts isn't always possible.
- Emergency money should stay in taxable or savings accounts you can reach without penalties.
- Future tax rates are uncertain, and required minimum distributions from traditional IRAs can push you into higher brackets later.
- Small accounts may not be worth splitting; a single balanced fund can be simpler.
Try it with the Tax-Equivalent Yield Calculator
- Open the Tax-Equivalent Yield Calculator and enter your income, filing status and state tax rate.
- Enter a municipal bond yield and the taxable bond or CD yield you could get instead.
- See which is better after tax in a taxable account, then hold taxable bonds in your IRA or 401(k) when you have room.
Frequently asked questions
Does asset location matter if all my money is in retirement accounts?
Only between traditional and Roth accounts. Without a taxable account, the main choice is putting higher-growth investments in the Roth.
Should bonds always go in the IRA?
Usually, when interest rates are meaningful and you're in a middle or high bracket. With very low bond yields, the advantage shrinks.
Is asset location worth the trouble?
For investors with sizable money in both taxable and tax-advantaged accounts, it's one of the few ways to raise after-tax returns without taking more risk.